4 Comments
User's avatar
Mañana's avatar

Foucault got some things wrong on Iran but you should know there's much that's wrong with your account. I'll make one point, which is representative, and leave it at that.

The piece opens by placing Michel Foucault in the company of Beatrice Webb, who defended Stalin’s show trials. Yet when Iran’s revolutionary tribunals began handing down death sentences, Foucault publicly challenged their conduct. In April 1979, he wrote to Prime Minister Mehdi Bazargan insisting that even the most reviled defendants were entitled to the fullest means of defence. A month later, in Le Monde, he described the clerical government as bloody and insisted that rights must place limits on every government. Your account ends before either intervention. They are both readily available and undermine the comparison which motivates the piece.

Tarik Zukic's avatar

I wanted to comment in a similar manner, to mention Sartre and Heidegger who knew they supported bloody regimes and continued to do so, but then realised that this article is the simplest right-wing bashing of postmodernism.

In Analysis with Madonna's avatar

Makes one wonder just how wise a philosopher Foucault really was, regardless of all the praise he got.

A gay atheist philosopher like him would have been among the first to be executed in the new theocratic Iran.

Analytik's avatar

What is interesting is that in much of American philosophical commentary the oeuvre is often obfuscated by the fixation on the personality or morality of its author. This inquisitorial tendency is a leitmotif in American philosophical commentary. A commentator below mentions the fact that Foucault criticised the theocratic republic. I is true, but that does not resolve the problem of explaining how a philosopher with his nominalist tendencies became fascinated with a theocratic regime. Theocratic regimes are always “totalising”.